I am in a situation where I can have my phone on charge for a majority of the time and usually need to.
I use my device heavily: I am always connected to net for RSS feeds with Push emails coming down during my waking hours; I regularly surf the web, usually from rss feeds or browsing this forum; listen to music and/or TomTom while travelling and watch YouTube videos as often as somebody enquires "have you seen that?".
My battery will usually last me less than one day when I am in full multimedia mode, but it will last for a couple of quite days when I'm only texting/emailing and using it as my watch.
This causes me no concern and an extended battery would only be a consideration with a smaller device such as the Diamond or Touch Pro.
I have a friend with a Nokia N95. This device is larger than my Touch Cruise and he is only a light user, but the battery will drain within a few hours if he even dares to make a phone call. For him the battery life is a definite consideration for his next phone.
For me, size is all important. I want the functionality of Windows Mobile, but I wouldn't pay the price of turning it into a brick just for longer battery life. This is why the Touch Diamond and Pro are looking more and more promising.